
As I mentioned in the box cookie mix post of last week, it is entirely possible to make healthy and delicious cookies from scratch. And yes, ones that don’t taste like a patchouli-scented hippie named Sunrise made them. The secret to these ones, as is the secret to many things in life, is a little bit of hooch. Just a wee bit, for flavouring. Booze is my favourite spice, after all. And it’s not as if there’s enough to get anyone tipsy.
The original recipe is from 1001 Cookie Recipes by Gregg R. Gillespie, but we’re veering far off-course from his original intent. I’m providing the original recipe with my substitutions in italics after, plus notes at the end on the various ingredient changes. The end product here is a cookie that is crunchy on the outside, chewy on the inside, with a great texture and a kiss of Amaretto.
Cornflake Cookies
2 cups all-purpose flour (2 cups spelt flour) [1]
2 tsp baking powder
1 cup butter at room temperature (1 cup non-hydrogenated margarine) [2]
1 cup granulated sugar
1 cup brown sugar [3]
2 large eggs
1 Tbsp Amaretto
2 cups cornflakes (2 cups high-fibre mixed cereal) [4]
1 cup flaked coconut
Preheat the oven to 375′ F.
In a large bowl cream the butter and two sugars. Beat in the eggs and the Amaretto. Gradually blend in the flour and baking powder. Fold in the corn flakes and coconut.
Pinch off walnut-sized pieces of dough and roll into balls. Place 1-1/2 inches apart on ungreased baking sheets.
Bake for 10 to 12 minutes until lightly coloured. Transfer to wire racks to cool. (The original recipe also calls to sprinkle the warm cookies with icing sugar but that just makes them messy.)
Ingredient notes:
[1] Any whole grain flour would work here; spelt, kamut, whole wheat or rye.
[2] In Canada, President’s Choice makes a margarine called “Memories of Butter” - completely non-hydrogenated, yet still the right consistency to use in baking.
[3] You could easily cut both sugars by 1/4 to 1/3 and have no detrimental effects. The inclusion of the Amaretto and the coconut makes these quite sweet. More than a third will mess up the consistency, though.
[4] I use a cereal by Nature’s Path (ironically the same company that made the hated cookie mix) called Optimum Power. There’s 10g of fibre in a 3/4 cup serving, which would drag Cornflakes out back and kick its ass. Optimum Power has dried blueberries in the mix, and the addition of more dried blueberries would make this cookie even better.
One of the cool things about writing a book about a particular food item is that, whether you consider yourself to be or not, other people will look to you as an expert on that topic, and will heap free samples upon you in the hope that you will write about them. I met author Steve Almond as he was being gifted with container after container of free organic cotton candy. Despite his polite insistence that he couldn’t possibly carry six tubs of cotton candy home on a plane, the manufacturer wanted him to try every flavor.
Along the way, he shares his personal candy quirks: he dislikes maple, compares coconut to bits of torn-off hangnails (which made me look at both coconut and hangnails in a very different light), and interviews chocolate engineer Dave Bolton, who compares the taste of mainstream milk chocolate to baby vomit. As a chocolate snob myself, I’d have to agree with Bolton – I never really had the right words to describe that slightly sour tang most milk chocolate bars have, and now I do.



I spent Saturday in a conference room full of farmers and nutritionists. I scored a media pass to the Canadian Organic Growers conference, and besides the free organic lunch, everyone went home with a bag of organic swag. Most of the stuff was from
The instructions were simple, dump the mix into a bowl and add 1/3 cup of oil and 5 Tablespoons of water. Which left me with a greasy, gritty dough. I checked the ingredients - organic whole wheat flour, organic sugar, organic chocolate chips, organic wheat bran, sea salt, organic soy flour, and some natural preservatives. Fair enough.
They looked a little weird when I pulled the pan out of the oven. Sort of… lumpy. Then the taste test confirmed it - those were some damned gritty cookies. If I had to explain them, I’d say they were like cookies made on the beach - salty and gritty. Part of this obviously comes from the fact that they’re made with whole wheat and bran. This makes for a much healthier cookie, but the mouthfeel was just too weird. This is what all those poor children born to hippies had to endure until retirement savings plans lured their parents off the commune and into yuppiedom.
So the final judgment - I’ll take a pass. I’ve no idea how much such mixes go for in the supermarket or health food store, but it’s probably too much. The tiny amount of time saved really isn’t the tradeoff - there was still mixing to be done and only slightly fewer dishes to be washed than with a “from scratch” recipe. One of the positive aspects regularly mentioned with baking mixes is that the cook isn’t required to have a variety of flours and other ingredients on hand to make the item. This one didn’t even require an egg, and is, in fact, vegan - if you don’t count the fact that it was made in a facility that processes other products that contain milk.





